Healthy Forests Hold Water,
Felice Pace, Guest Comment
Capitol Press, 1/20/2006
The editors of Capital
Press used the occasion of the recent California floods to editorialize on the state’s water and flood control needs (Jan. 13, 2006
We can all agree with the editorial’s conclusion: “Now is the time to prepare for what is
coming... we need to make sure the state continues to have the water it needs... to grow.” In order to
achieve water security, Capital Press’ editors say that additional surface water storage throughout the
state is needed.
This is, of course, the traditional solution. But dams and reservoirs have proven
to be inadequate for flood protection and they carry costs – including loss of valuable fisheries and
wildlife habitat, historical and archeological resources – none of which were considered when they were
built. For these and other reasons, it is unlikely that many (if any) large, new storage projects will be
built in California.
Furthermore, because global warming is reducing the mountain snow pack,
California will have trouble keeping its existing reservoirs filled. More water will be dumped in winter
to prevent flooding and dam failure and less will be available during the dry summers.
So what is a
thirsty state to do?
The answer is all around us if we only look up.
and the rest of the West’s mountains are largely covered by forests and forest soils are by far our
largest water reservoir. In fact, our forested uplands are already more valuable for the water they store
and slowly release than for the timber that has traditionally been the focus of upland economic activity.
But California and the rest of the American West have not yet learned what most of the world
understands – that upland forest protection and water security are one and the same. Instead, we are
still allowing corporations like Sierra Pacific Industries to clear-cut our forested mountains.
While science and experience clearly show that industrial logging compacts forest soils and destroying
the soil’s water storage capacity, the political power of Red Emerson’s Sierra Pacific Industries is such
that politicians not only allow it to continue destroying California’s forest reservoir but to get away
with claiming that destructive logging is reducing fire danger and increasing water supplies in the
When will Californians wake up and realize that the key to water security is protecting
the forested upland watersheds that store the majority of our water and – when the forests are healthy –
release this water slowly over the course of California’s long, dry summers?
When will we overcome
our denial and realize that more dams and surface reservoirs are not the answer?
Felice Pace of
Klamath, Calif., is a former conservation director of the Klamath Forest Alliance.
accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and as defined under the provisions of "fair use", any
copyrighted material herein is distributed without profit or payment for non-profit research and for
educational use by our membership.